Asset Sale vs Share Sale: What You Need to Know
When selling or buying a business, the decision between an asset sale and a share sale can significantly impact the transaction’s structure, tax implications, and risks.
An asset sale involves transferring specific business assets like equipment, inventory, and goodwill, while a share sale entails purchasing the company’s ownership shares.
Understanding the key differences between these two methods ensures you make informed decisions that align with your objectives.
What is an Asset Sale?
In an asset sale, you sell individual business components, such as property, stock, intellectual property, and equipment, rather than the entire company entity. As the buyer, you gain control of selected assets without taking on liabilities unless specifically agreed upon.
Benefits of an Asset Sale
Selective Asset Transfer: You can acquire or sell only the desired assets, excluding unwanted liabilities or obligations.
Tax Advantages for Buyers: Buyers can benefit from higher depreciation claims on acquired assets.
Considerations for an Asset Sale
Complex Contracts: The sale requires detailed agreements to list each asset and specify exclusions.
Employee Transition: Employees may need to be re-hired under new contracts, adding complexity to the process.
Key Takeaway: An asset sale offers flexibility in asset selection but can involve intricate contracts and additional administrative steps.
What is a Share Sale?
A share sale involves purchasing or selling a company’s ownership shares. As the buyer, you acquire the entire entity, including its assets, liabilities, and contractual obligations. For sellers, this method often leads to a cleaner exit.
Benefits of a Share Sale
Simplicity in Ownership Transfer: Ownership passes through the share transfer without needing to reassign assets or contracts.
Continuity for Employees: Employees remain under the same employer, maintaining existing entitlements.
Considerations for a Share Sale
Liabilities Transfer: Buyers inherit all liabilities and risks associated with the company, including tax and legal obligations.
Due Diligence Required: A comprehensive review of the company’s records is necessary to identify potential risks.
Key Takeaway: Share sales provide a straightforward transfer of ownership but require thorough due diligence to manage inherited risks.
Tax Implications of Asset Sale vs Share Sale
Asset Sale Tax Implications
For sellers, an asset sale may result in higher tax liabilities due to the capital gains on individual assets. Buyers, however, can benefit from depreciation deductions on the purchased assets.
Share Sale Tax Implications
In a share sale, sellers often benefit from concessional capital gains tax treatment, such as small business CGT concessions. Buyers, however, cannot depreciate the company’s assets as they would in an asset sale.
Key Takeaway: Tax outcomes differ significantly between asset and share sales, making professional advice invaluable for maximising benefits.
Need a Lawyer?
Liabilities and Risks
Asset Sale Risks
Buyers typically avoid inheriting liabilities unless explicitly agreed upon. However, this can make negotiations around warranties and indemnities more complex.
Share Sale Risks
Buyers inherit all disclosed and undisclosed company liabilities, including debts, employee entitlements, and legal claims. Conducting thorough due diligence is essential to mitigate these risks.
Key Takeaway: Asset sales limit liability exposure for buyers, while share sales require in-depth due diligence to manage inherited risks.
Impact on Employees and Contracts
Asset Sale
Employees are not automatically transferred in an asset sale and must be re-employed by the buyer. Contracts with customers or suppliers may also need renegotiation or assignment.
Share Sale
Since the entity remains unchanged, employees and contracts are automatically retained in a share sale, simplifying the transition process.
Key Takeaway: Share sales ensure continuity for employees and contracts, while asset sales may require renegotiations and new agreements.
When to Choose an Asset Sale or Share Sale?
Choose an Asset Sale If:
- You want to avoid inheriting liabilities.
- You prefer to acquire specific assets without taking over the entire company.
Choose a Share Sale If:
- You aim for a seamless transfer of ownership, including contracts and employees.
- You want to maintain the company’s established structure and operations.
Key Takeaway: Your choice should align with your goals, risk tolerance, and the nature of the transaction.
The decision between selling an asset and selling a share depends on your objectives, tax implications, and risk considerations.
Buyers and sellers should carefully evaluate the benefits and challenges of each option, ensuring the transaction aligns with their financial and operational goals.
Seeking professional advice can provide clarity and support throughout the process.
